Anatomy of a deal: Dell in the Triad

Friday, November 05, 2004

The North Carolina legislature approved a $242 million package for Dell and a facility that could lead to 2,000 jobs ($121,000 per job). Pretty steep price to pay. Read more.

(It's not over: Now that state incentives are lined up, Dell will start milking additional incentives from local governments. Read more.)

To give you some sense of the priorities, that level of incentive could provide remedial reading instruction to about 70,000 first graders in North Carolina. (My calculation is based on the cost of Reading Recovery, an early intervention program. School districts report the cost per student ranges from $2,300 to $3,500. Learn more.)

In an economy that must run on brainpower, does it make sense for the legislature to provide Dell nearly one-quarter billion in incentives, or make investments in early education? The paybacks from early childhood education are becoming very clear. Learn more.

The case for backing Dell to this extent is far less clear. North Carolina runs a sizable risk of angering other technology companies with an incentive package that is too big. Read more.

Here is a good report from the University of California, Irvine that demonstrates that in Dell's location decisions, incentives are a third tier variable. Download the report.

posted by Ed Morrison |

Subscribe with Bloglines






Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
links
Google
The Web EDPro Weblog